| OBJECTIVES
Scientists from several Flemish and international
research units have undertaken to consider the
nature of publications on university history, a
significant proportion of which take the form of
one-off works. At the same time, they intend to
reflect on the relationship between university
history, intellectual history and scientific
history. They believe that new theoretical
insights in this area could result in greater
interaction. New tools are also required if this
renewed university history is to be pursued. It
is explicitly intended to introduce modern
electronic processing, editing and publishing
techniques to the field of university history, by
producing automated and accessible bibliographies,
archive guides, text editions, prosopographic
databases of students and professors, etc.
The final objective is to disseminate the results
of the discussions in written form and to publish
test cases that can serve as models. Another
intended result is to provide a paradigm for
universities celebrating anniversaries and their
historiographers, by indicating how they can best
use the historical output of that moment in such
a way as to advance university history as a whole,
rather than simply that of their own institution.
PROPOSED
PROGRAMMING
The following
themes are proposed in the request.
I.
Institutionalised collaboration between the International
Commission for the History of Universities and
the journal History of Universities
The lack of
scope and resources at these two organisations
made it important for the Scientific Research
Network to take the matter to heart. This relates,
amongst other things, to the progress of the
ongoing international bibliography and the
setting up (electronically) of an international
retrospective bibliography. The Scientific
Research Network can co-ordinate and stimulate
these activities.
II. New
methods, techniques and tools
Request:
Develop or work out methods, techniques and tools,
taking account of modern electronic possibilities,
which could help determine the direction of co-ordinated
research in the field of university history from
the Middle Ages to the present day. This will
relate in the first instance to the structure and
accessibility of bibliographies, archive guides,
text editions and prosopographic databases of
students and professors.
Projects to
be formulated:
1.
Bibliographies
The University of Louvain will be used as a test
case for the formulation of a model of a
retrospective bibliography. It is one of the few
European universities to have enjoyed a
continuous existence since the Middle Ages, and
this in a sequence of forms (University of
Louvain 1425-1797, Rijksuniversiteit (in the
United Netherlands) 1816-1835, Catholic
University 1834 and split into Flemish and
Francophone institutions in 1968-1970). A variety
of bibliographies already exist, and an ongoing
bibliography has been maintained since 1973.
It must first be investigated what
bibliographical systems are available and whether
it would be useful to adopt one of them.
2. Archive
management and archive guides
Two themes are proposed with respect to
university archives.
2.1. A wide-ranging
archival debate needs to be fostered among
practitioners of university history regarding the
management of university and scientific archives.
There is an international discussion under way
between archivists concerning which university
archives ought to be preserved. In June 1998, the
Nederlandse Werkgroep Universiteitsgeschiedenis
and the Belgian Studium Generale association held
a joint study day devoted to the issue at the
Free University Amsterdam. It was apparent at
this time that Belgium plays a major role at the
International Council on Archives, Section of
University and Research Institution Archives (ICA/SUV).
A. Despy Meyer of the ULB is secretary of the
section, F. Scheelings of the VUB is a member of
the section's Steering Committee and D. Devriese
of the ULB is a specialist in scientific archives.
Together, they are the driving force behind
activities at the aforementioned international
organisation, in which a new approach is being
pursued towards the management of archives at
universities and other scientific institutions. A
central issue is the search for a compromise
between the loss of all data on the one hand and
the maintenance of an unmanageable mass of
research data in electronic form on the other.
They are also working on an almost completed
manual for the management of university archives.
They will certainly be involved in the
discussions of 'archive guides'. These
discussions are very important to the themes
discussed in sections III and IV.
2.2. The
desirability of formulating a model for an
annotated archive guide for each university has
been discussed for several years now within the
International Commission for the History
of Universities and within the Belgian and Dutch
working groups on university history. Many
contacts have already been established with
archivists' bodies and associations. Louvain also
serves as an interesting test case for the
archive guide because of its long history and
complex structures. The aim is to produce a
finished, published archive guide for Louvain,
which will then be able to serve as a model.
Physical and iconographic sources were not
mentioned in the request, but ought certainly to
be included.
3. Text
editions
A great deal of thought is currently being
devoted to new methods for publishing, or rather
improving the accessibility of, large series of
sources. This problem also applies, of course, to
university sources. Rather than waiting to see
what the various national institutes come up with
in terms of text editions, university historians
- in consultation, of course, with experts in
publishing techniques - are working out their own
systems.
It is not the intention that members of the group
should produce a stream of text editions. The
objective is a report setting out the results of
the discussion of the use of modern media and
techniques in the publication of texts from the
university environment. If an edition is prepared,
it ought to be conceived as a model for other
projects.
4.
Prosopographic databases of students and
professors
4.1. Large databases of students and/or lecturers
have been set up in a variety of countries. Each
one is structured in a slightly different way and
uses different methods and software. The minimum
result we are aiming it is to formulate a method
for the initial approach (how to address the
issue, what sources to consider, etc.). As
explained in the request, the University of
Louvain will be used as a test case. In order to
achieve this, a thoroughgoing discussion will be
needed with experts in databases and digitisation.
4.2. An important aspect of this work is the
reconstruction of student populations for
universities whose matriculation and/or
graduation lists have been lost or never existed.
The University of Douai during the Habsburg
period will be used as a test case (1559-1668;
under French administration 1668-1795). This
institution was extremely important during the
Counter-Reformation and the re-Catholicisation of
the Protestant countries. Partial reconstructions
have already been carried out for several
universities (e.g.: the fourth matriculation list
at Louvain 1569-1616 by Peter Vandermeersch;
Pavia in the 15th century by Agostino Sottili;
the Athenaeum Illustre in Amsterdam 1632-1704 by
Dirk van Miert).
III. Reflection on university historiography
Reflection is
necessary regarding the different objectives of
university history, including the extent to which
the popular commemorative publications of
individual universities contribute to a better
knowledge of the history of universities in
general and, as a related issue, the extent to
which special editions and other forms of
university historiography contribute or ought to
contribute to reflection on the future of the
university. One of the intended results of this
reflection is to present a paradigm to
universities celebrating anniversaries and their
historians, according to which they can use the
historical production of that moment in a more
useful way in order to promote university history
in general rather than just the specific history
of their own institution.
IV. Reflection on an integrated 'intellectual'
history
Reflecting on
the relationship between university history,
intellectual history and scientific history. The
different areas of science do not work together
sufficiently, partly because they use different
paradigms and the methods they use are not
sufficiently co-ordinated. New theoretical
insights can lead to greater interaction.
WORKING METHOD AND INSTRUMENTS
The intention
is for members of FASTI to organise workshops on
the different themes, to which experts on the
relevant theme can be invited. The Scientific
Research Network can and will share in the costs
so far as its budget will allow. It has been
calculated that the available finance will be
sufficient for a maximum of two meetings of
around 20 people. The manner in which the results
of the workshops will be presented in written
form has to be discussed at the plenary meeting.
Examples are a 'grey' series (working papers)
which might, for instance, be distributed via a
dedicated website.
It is
certainly intended to make far-reaching use of
electronic resources as part of the 'new working
instruments' aspect. Consideration will thus be
required of the ways in which the electronic
databases to be created will be made available.
|