In
a frightening but long expected move, Israeli prime minister Ehud
Olmert has brought the Yisrael Beitenu party into his coalition
government. The party's leader, Avigdor Lieberman, is to be vice prime
minister and, as "Minister for Strategic Threats," a key member of
Israel's "security cabinet" in charge of the Iran portfolio.
Yisrael Beitenu is a dangerous extremist party with fascist tendencies
that has openly advocated the "transfer" of Palestinians, including the
transfer of Arab towns within Israel to a Bantustan-like future
Palestinian entity. It has made clear that a Jewish supremacist state
is more important than a democratic one. The party, whose strongest
base is among Russian immigrants brought to Israel in the 1990s, surged
at the Israeli election earlier this year, taking eleven seats in
Israel's 120 seat Knesset.
Last summer, Israel launched a disastrous war of destruction against
Lebanon, and continues its siege and onslaught against Palestinians in
the occupied territories which has killed nearly three hundred people in three months and left
hundreds of thousands without sufficient food, water and electricity.
Lieberman has advocated even more harsh and criminal measures against
the Palestinians and Israel's neighbors.
It is dismaying that the European Union, a key international actor,
seems set to maintain warm, normal relations with this extremist
government, thus giving it encouragement and legitimacy.
"You will understand that we cannot interfere with the setting up of a
foreign government. This is a matter for which the concerned State
alone is responsible," wrote Cristina Gallach, the official spokesperson for Javier Solana, the EU
High Representative for foreign policy, in an email responding to a
query about whether the EU would impose sanctions on Israel if Yisrael
Beitenu joined the government.
Gallach added that "We think that both Israel and the Palestinians are
aware of the responsibility they have in creating the favorable
conditions for reactivating the
Peace Process with the ultimate goal of having two States living side
by side in peace and security." Other than such bland and cynical
platitudes, Solana's spokesperson offered no hint of EU concern about
the horrifying political developments within Israel that are certain to
bring about further violence, escalation and needless suffering.
In an interview with an Israeli newspaper in September, Yisrael Beitenu
leader Lieberman said: "The vision I would like to see here is the
entrenching of the Jewish and the Zionist state...I very much favour
democracy, but when there is a contradiction between democratic and
Jewish values, the Jewish and Zionist values are more important."
(Scotsman, October 23, 2006)
In addition to espousing ethnic cleansing, Lieberman has a long history
of inciting discrimination, hatred and violence against Palestinians
within the Jewish state and living under Israeli military occupation in East Jerusalem, the West
Bank and Gaza Strip. When he served as minister of transport in a
previous government, Lieberman called for all Palestinian prisoners
held by the Israeli occupation authorities to be drowned in the Dead
Sea and offered to provide the buses ("Lieberman blasted for suggesting
drowning Palestinian prisoners," Ha'aretz, July 11, 2002). He has
proposed to strip the citizenship of, and expel any Palestinian citizen
of Israel who refuses to sign a loyalty oath to the Jewish Zionist
state ("A Jewish demographic state," Ha'aretz, June 28, 2002).
In 2002, Lieberman declared, "I would not hesitate to send the Israeli
army into all of Area A [the area of the West Bank ostensibly under
Palestinian Authority control] for 48 hours. Destroy the foundation of
all the authority's military infrastructure, all of the police
buildings, the arsenals, all the posts of the security forces... not
leave one stone on another. Destroy everything." He also suggested to
the Israeli cabinet that the air force systematically bomb all the
commercial centers, gas stations and banks in the occupied territories (The Independent, March
7, 2002). And, he has proposed bombing Egypt's Aswan Dam, despite that
country's peace treaty with Israel since 1979. What will he propose to
do to Iran?
Hebrew University professor Ze'ev Sternhell, a leading Israeli academic
specialist on fascism and totalitarianism, was quoted by the Scotsman
newspaper as terming Lieberman "perhaps the most dangerous politician
in the history of the state of Israel."
Urgent action is needed to stem the growing threat to international
peace and security that Israel presents. Rather than do anything of the
kind, the office of the EU High Representative has set a new low standard, offering only
appeasement and accomodation for Israeli extremism and apartheid. The
claim that the EU does not interfere in the internal affairs of foreign
governments is just a fig leaf for political cowardice and
unwillingness to stand up to Israel or its backers; it is not remotely
consistent with past or present practice in other cases.
Most glaringly, since Palestinians under occupation elected Hamas to
lead the Palestinian Authority last January, in the Arab world's most
free election ever, the
EU has interfered in their affairs in the most irresponsible manner,
imposing a total siege and cut off of aid that has directly penalized
the Palestinian population, causing widespread hunger and deprivation.
This siege is explicitly intended to force the Hamas-led authority to
abandon the platform on which it was elected, or to force it out of office completely. (The EU claims it wants Hamas
to recognize Israel and end violence, even though Hamas has observed a
22-month one-sided truce, halting attacks on Israel, and its leaders
have issued repeated statements in favor of reaching a long-term
agreement with Israel on the basis of equality and mutual, not
one-sided, recognition.)
The European Union, under Solana's personal stewardship, orchestrated
this gross nterference in the development of Palestinian democracy and
punishment of those who tried to practice it.
And in 2000, EU countries took the unprecedented measure of imposing
diplomatic sanctions on one of their own member states, Austria, after
the far-right Freedom Party joined the government following elections.
Although many voices criticized the EU for meddling in the internal
affairs of a democratic country, one of the most vocal supporters of
the sanctions was none other than Javier Solana, who on that occasion
declared: "I think Europe has given a very good example of how in
important things -- things that have to go with principles, with values
-- there's no possibility of compromise." ("Sanctions hit Austria,"
Reuters, February 4, 2000).
But when it comes to EU member states discharging their
responsibilities to hold Israel accountable for its escalating
violations of the EU-Israel Association Agreement, the Fourth Geneva Convention, numerous UN Security Council
Resolutions, and basic human decency, the principles that Solana and
many powerful others are so proud to boast of are nowhere to be found.
In this moral and
political vacuum, it is ever
more urgent to heed the call of Palestinian civil society to join the
growing global campaign of boycott, divestment and sanctions.